Thursday, November 10, 2016
The Miracle on 5th Avenue: A Holiday Fantasy
I've been listening to various supporters of Donald Trump, and especially several advisers to his transition team. The unifying theme of their comments is that he will change more or less on a cellular level by surrounding himself with intelligent, and experienced people who will guide him in decision making. The story I'm hearing is that the crazy ideas, the racism, bigotry, ill manners and general ignorance of government will all disappear as he changes into a man who, at 70, becomes a thoughtful individual who never acts rash or rude and follows the advice of those around him who understand the job he is about to undertaken. I'm an optimist at heart and am completely willing to believe this can happen. I also need to see results. A first major test of this holiday story line will be whether or not the President-Elect divests himself of all his business holdings, and of course not just the silly idea of turning them over to his children, but the entire family divesting themselves and everything placed in a blind trust by the time he takes office in two months. Anything short of that would create a mine field of conflicting interests and render him incapable of being President. I realize that placing such a large company with it's connections to foreign governments in a blind trust in two months time would be a huge undertaking, but if his supporters can believe that he will change into a completely different person in that amount of time, I'm sure we all could believe such a miracle would occur.
What I Know (post election reflection)
What I know: I am still the same person I was yesterday, the day before and tomorrow. I hold the same values that motivate and inspire me - simplicity, peace, integrity, equality, conservation of our natural world and community. Sometimes I see those values reflected in the leadership of our country and sometimes not. Sometimes my work is devoted more towards moving those ideals forward and sometimes the energy is directed more towards defending them. I am old enough to recall decades like the 1980s where my primary work was standing up for those principles against the prevailing political winds. I see a new storm blew in last night, I am pretty sure I know what my job will be. Time to get to work.
Thursday, March 31, 2016
Thank You Donald Trump
This political season has certainly been entertaining, although painful to watch and for that we can thank Donald Trump for his off-handed thoughtless comments tossed to the eager fans like cheap, sweatshop made t-shirts hurled by an outlandish mascot at a sporting event. Come to think of it, Trump really is the outlandish mascot of the current GOP, all we need is a little dance on the dugout roof or push-ups after a touchdown and the image would be complete.
As bizarre and ridiculous as his whole campaign has been to this point, the moment that prompted the "Thank You" on my part was his comments on abortion this week where he said a woman should be punished for having an abortion assuming it was illegal as he proposes to make the practice. Of course all hell broke loose on all side of the abortion debate but strangely enough his comment is perfectly logical and we owe him a debt of gratitude for pointing out the obvious. If abortion was illegal then it follows that there must be a penalty. There have been several studies done of the so-called "Pro-Life" movement and just about every case people who are pushing to make abortion illegal have no idea what to do in terms of punishment - fines? prison? Forget for the moment that there's no real evidence that making abortion illegal will prevent it from ever happening, just consider the rather strange position of someone trying to make a currently legal practice into a crime but having no idea what the punishment for that crime might be. In most cases people haven't even thought about the fact that crimes and punishment go hand in hand.
The Pro-Life movement, when they have accepted that there would be some punishment for an abortion, have presented the idea that only a doctor would be held responsible and punished. After all, women can't make decisions about their own lives can they? Next thing you know they'll want to own property and have jobs outside the house. As Trump quickly backtracked from his statements he settled on that absurd line of reasoning for a moment before moving on to "I was misquoted, taken out of context". Which, of course, when it was a direct answer to a direct question, but anything's possible this year, right?
Of course the Pro-Life position of punishing a doctor only is demeaning to women but it also fails miserably when considered within the current judicial system of this country. If we assume that a women who makes the decision to have an abortion is not guilty of anything but the doctor performing the procedure is, then we'd certainly have to release every prisoner who was convicted of drug possession charges. After all, they just used the drugs, the only person who could be sent to jail would be the seller of the illegal drugs.
Unfortunately the loudest voices of the Pro-Life movement are the least well informed and ironically the most harmful to what they claim to be their own mission. Fighting to close Planned Parenthood clinics in the name of being Pro-Life is akin to destroying fire hydrants in an attempt the protect neighborhoods from fires. Thank you Donald Trump for helping bring the absurdity of this position to light. While I'm sure there wasn't a lot of thought put into the statement, it may have a positive effect after all.
As bizarre and ridiculous as his whole campaign has been to this point, the moment that prompted the "Thank You" on my part was his comments on abortion this week where he said a woman should be punished for having an abortion assuming it was illegal as he proposes to make the practice. Of course all hell broke loose on all side of the abortion debate but strangely enough his comment is perfectly logical and we owe him a debt of gratitude for pointing out the obvious. If abortion was illegal then it follows that there must be a penalty. There have been several studies done of the so-called "Pro-Life" movement and just about every case people who are pushing to make abortion illegal have no idea what to do in terms of punishment - fines? prison? Forget for the moment that there's no real evidence that making abortion illegal will prevent it from ever happening, just consider the rather strange position of someone trying to make a currently legal practice into a crime but having no idea what the punishment for that crime might be. In most cases people haven't even thought about the fact that crimes and punishment go hand in hand.
The Pro-Life movement, when they have accepted that there would be some punishment for an abortion, have presented the idea that only a doctor would be held responsible and punished. After all, women can't make decisions about their own lives can they? Next thing you know they'll want to own property and have jobs outside the house. As Trump quickly backtracked from his statements he settled on that absurd line of reasoning for a moment before moving on to "I was misquoted, taken out of context". Which, of course, when it was a direct answer to a direct question, but anything's possible this year, right?
Of course the Pro-Life position of punishing a doctor only is demeaning to women but it also fails miserably when considered within the current judicial system of this country. If we assume that a women who makes the decision to have an abortion is not guilty of anything but the doctor performing the procedure is, then we'd certainly have to release every prisoner who was convicted of drug possession charges. After all, they just used the drugs, the only person who could be sent to jail would be the seller of the illegal drugs.
Unfortunately the loudest voices of the Pro-Life movement are the least well informed and ironically the most harmful to what they claim to be their own mission. Fighting to close Planned Parenthood clinics in the name of being Pro-Life is akin to destroying fire hydrants in an attempt the protect neighborhoods from fires. Thank you Donald Trump for helping bring the absurdity of this position to light. While I'm sure there wasn't a lot of thought put into the statement, it may have a positive effect after all.
Sunday, March 15, 2015
After The Testing is Done, What Then?
If you've followed any of the stories about standardized testing in recent years you've no doubt read about all the time taken up either preparing for tests or taking the actual tests. It is true that there's a lot of time in both of these areas. At my own school we've just begun the new computer based online tests (early March as I write this) and they're scheduled through mid-May. Yes, that's right three months. By any standards that's quite a lot of time in the school days taken up with students navigating or trying to (as there are often technical glitches) online tests. We could talk about what else students might be doing during this time or how the intense focus on tests shapes curriculum but I'd like to look at some of the things I'm noticing as a school teacher that I'll put in the "Brave New World" folder. One example is the issue of technical glitches in the testing environment. There has always been a huge focus on the testing environment. Cell phones are not allowed in the classroom, computers often can't be turned on, students are not allowed to come and go at will, and these are just a few of the rules put in place to make sure the testing environment hasn't been compromised. Now that the tests are online I see students who will be "dropped", the wireless goes down in the building, there's an issue at the server or any number of other issues comes along and they're stranded while a teacher helps them get back online. Some students may wait twenty minutes before being able to log back on to the test, perhaps the work they had been in the middle of may be there, or maybe not. Now suppose you take two students in a class who are taking the same test, one has to log on more than once as one of the technical glitches kicks them out of the test, the other has no issues. Can we call their testing experience equal? The whole point of the standardized test is that all students are tested equally. Has the testing environment be compromised in anyway? So far I haven't heard anyone addressing that issue. It may well be that the online testing format is the best option we have considering the speed at which the information can be processed and results returned to the schools, but its clearly far from perfect, maybe even far from good. I'm not against online testing but think for a moment of the last time you opened a text book, had the words suddenly disappeared? Did a teacher tell you to close the book and open it again to see if they had come back? Even the tech savvy computer experts have issues from time to time, and when you have hundreds of students logging on to a test site you can bet that the problems will be more often than not. I haven't heard any discussion on this point and it seems like just one of those things we are to accept as the new norm. The disconnect for me comes from operating with what might be an old set of expectations in a new norm. If having the student log into the test possibly several times is okay, then the definition of the testing environment has changed and we should acknowledge that change.
One of the promises of the new tests is the rich data that can be mined from the results. I've been in meetings where the presenter will talk with great passion about how we can dig down deep in the data to learn more than ever before about students abilities and pinpoint areas of weakness. That may be but what will we do with all this information? At the elementary school level it will still likely be one teacher and twenty five to thirty five students. I have yet to hear any insights on how that teacher will be able to alter time and space to be able to teach each student individually to cover all the areas where they need to improve. Consider that if a student is below grade level in reading skills, say perhaps they are a fourth grade student reading a second grade level, studies show that they would need extra work beyond the regular school day, perhaps an extra two hours per day of focused instruction to get on track. Any teacher could tell you that you don't need a series of tests to find out if a student can't read effectively at their grade level, from my experience you can determine this kind of information within the first week of school.
The latest tests promise to deliver data that is more nuanced and specific than ever before. We're told that we can learn the particular style of non-fiction texts that a student has trouble understanding for example. If school districts were funded to a level where they could employ a whole host of specialists just as a football team has coaches for the receivers, the linebackers, the running backs, etc. then we might be able to do something with all this data. If these tests can show us, as they promise, the exact elements of a child's reading abilities for example that need more work, who will do the work of guiding that student? Are we really expecting a single teacher to be the expert in every area and have the time and space to work one on one with every student?
The current testing structure takes a lot of time and energy. The benefit we're told is the rich data. If that data, however, has no realistic way of being used to meaningfully impact students then is it worth the time we take to discover it?
We are living in an interesting time indeed and I'm quite aware of that expression being used as a curse. More and more data is available at every turn. I can check my email now by simply looking at my wrist, never mind the outdated and difficult task of taking a mobile device out of my pocket. In the world of consumer electronics we're trading money for these gadgets as well as the time spent looking at and consuming the data they provide and it is always worth asking if the deal is fair. Is this worth the cost? With the current trends in school testing we are also spending money, our tax dollars to be specific. Is it worth the cost? Could the millions paid to companies to produce and administer the tests be used better elsewhere? Is it worth the time? Make no mistake, when you are testing for several months out of the school year somethings are dropped from the school day. Perhaps it's shorter recess times or maybe independent reading or the chance to develop a science experiment based on some new information you've read about.
The current push for data has very real costs in time and money. If, as I would maintain, the data has little to no value due to the inability to use it in any meaningful way to positively impact the student's learning then I believe the costs are too high. We are not getting a good deal.
One of the promises of the new tests is the rich data that can be mined from the results. I've been in meetings where the presenter will talk with great passion about how we can dig down deep in the data to learn more than ever before about students abilities and pinpoint areas of weakness. That may be but what will we do with all this information? At the elementary school level it will still likely be one teacher and twenty five to thirty five students. I have yet to hear any insights on how that teacher will be able to alter time and space to be able to teach each student individually to cover all the areas where they need to improve. Consider that if a student is below grade level in reading skills, say perhaps they are a fourth grade student reading a second grade level, studies show that they would need extra work beyond the regular school day, perhaps an extra two hours per day of focused instruction to get on track. Any teacher could tell you that you don't need a series of tests to find out if a student can't read effectively at their grade level, from my experience you can determine this kind of information within the first week of school.
The latest tests promise to deliver data that is more nuanced and specific than ever before. We're told that we can learn the particular style of non-fiction texts that a student has trouble understanding for example. If school districts were funded to a level where they could employ a whole host of specialists just as a football team has coaches for the receivers, the linebackers, the running backs, etc. then we might be able to do something with all this data. If these tests can show us, as they promise, the exact elements of a child's reading abilities for example that need more work, who will do the work of guiding that student? Are we really expecting a single teacher to be the expert in every area and have the time and space to work one on one with every student?
The current testing structure takes a lot of time and energy. The benefit we're told is the rich data. If that data, however, has no realistic way of being used to meaningfully impact students then is it worth the time we take to discover it?
We are living in an interesting time indeed and I'm quite aware of that expression being used as a curse. More and more data is available at every turn. I can check my email now by simply looking at my wrist, never mind the outdated and difficult task of taking a mobile device out of my pocket. In the world of consumer electronics we're trading money for these gadgets as well as the time spent looking at and consuming the data they provide and it is always worth asking if the deal is fair. Is this worth the cost? With the current trends in school testing we are also spending money, our tax dollars to be specific. Is it worth the cost? Could the millions paid to companies to produce and administer the tests be used better elsewhere? Is it worth the time? Make no mistake, when you are testing for several months out of the school year somethings are dropped from the school day. Perhaps it's shorter recess times or maybe independent reading or the chance to develop a science experiment based on some new information you've read about.
The current push for data has very real costs in time and money. If, as I would maintain, the data has little to no value due to the inability to use it in any meaningful way to positively impact the student's learning then I believe the costs are too high. We are not getting a good deal.
Monday, July 21, 2014
Who Will Be The Next Pete Seeger?
I’ve written before about Pete Seeger. In a previous article I called him “My
greatest teacher” and he was that as well as an endless source of inspiration
and ideas. Yesterday I watched the
concert at Lincoln Center as a part of Seeger Fest laughing, crying and singing
along and just immersing myself in the amazing “Pete-ness” of the whole
event. I was particularly struck by the
words from Harry Belafonte when he asked who would be the next Pete Seeger. This isn’t the first time I’ve thought about
this idea. In the worlds of music, art,
dance, or any creative venture there’s always a thought about what or who will
be the next big thing. I believe there
will never be another Pete Seeger.
That’s partly due to the amazing range of his accomplishments but also
due to a realization that the world has changed. Pete began his musical seed sowing when the
recording industry and radio were still relatively new. When the Weavers sold a couple of million
records that accounted for a huge percentage of the record buying public, when
they appeared on radio or TV with the small number of networks available, a
large portion of the country listened.
While most of us hold in our hands devices that can literally broadcast
around the world via social media the sheer number of people doing exactly the
same thing means that the chances of any one voice, idea or song being heard by
most of the population is decreased. The
media landscape that Pete walked through most of his life was such that when he
spoke it often carried more weight. What would be the modern day equivalent of
his performance of “Big Muddy” on The Smothers Brothers show? A You Tube clip?
Today’s version might reach several million but would it have the same impact?
I don’t think so. Pete’s regular column
in Sing Out! magazine might not have reached the same number that see one of
today’s popular bloggers but the audience that was reading was really paying
attention. In the grand scheme of
things, the readership of the “Appleseeds” column might not have been large,
but the percentage of readers who started writing their own songs, became
activists or joined political movements was huge.
There may be others who will work as tirelessly as Pete
Seeger at cleaning up rivers, opposing wars and violence and pushing for civil
rights and they may be every bit as good a musician as Pete (although that
would be quite a challenge!) but it will be different. As much as he would try to deny it, he was a
star, a major star, a super star, coming from a time in the world of commercial
music making where stars were made. That
star power is something we’re not likely to see again.
Of course if Pete was anything it was optimistic. I often heard him talk about the boundless
opportunities that existed for reaching out and sharing with others. Will there be another single individual who
will be connected to most, if not all of the major figures in American folk
music, introduce audiences to songs from all over the world, record multi-million
selling records, write songs that are covered hundreds if not thousands of
times in every language, invent essential language for music notation, write
the first important book on playing the banjo, influence millions of young
songwriters, musicians and activists through his endless travels? No, most
likely not. But, there are thousands and
maybe millions of people doing amazing and creative work that speaks to the
essential beauty of human dignity and they are sharing that work around the
word right now. Rather than wonder who
might be the next Pete Seeger I would suggest that we all have a part to play
in carrying on his work. The next Pete Seeger would not be recognizable if we’re
looking for anything like what we’ve seen before. We are all Pete Seeger now, and have been for
some time, perhaps the fact that Pete was still here might have blinded us to
that fact. We are all the seeds he planted
and we are the gardeners tending the fields for the future generations.
Here's a couple of photos I took of Pete over the years at People's Music Network gatherings.
Wednesday, March 5, 2014
Thinking out loud
I've been following the news from Ukraine this past week and am intrigued by many things I hear. One of the first statements that caught my attention was from Secretary of State John Kerry saying that "You don't just invade a country on phony pretexts to assert your interests". I would agree completely, in fact there are plenty of international treaties in place stating just that and add that one risks looking like a fool if you don't acknowledge that the United States is guilty of that exact same action, most recently in Iraq. Apparently I am not cut out for a job in politics because I don't think I could deliver a line like that with a straight face. I would at least have to add "Look, we should know, we've tried it time and time again, it just doesn't really work out, at least its not worth the costs involved." But, as I've said, that's not my job and I don't think I could do it anyway.
Presidential critics who last week were decrying his dictator-like-iron-grip-tyrannical personality now see him as weak because no foreign country would dare break international law if a real leader occupied the White House. The dizzying speed at which some folks rush to condemn anything that President Obama (or his wife for that matter) says and does has yielded many silly moments and this may just be one more in the long line, not worth even trying to understand let alone answer. The prize for most ridiculous has to go to the chorus from the right praising Putin and holding him up as an example of how to be a leader. As a teacher though I'm always looking for teachable moments and possibilities for learning.
I asked many of my POTUS hating friends for suggestions on what they would do, and of course this is not a scientific study, but the answers I got where mostly not answers at all. One person suggested the same economic or political sanctions that are currently being discussed but everyone else couldn't come up with anything they would do. A more interesting point I think is why should the President of the United States be the one who guarantees proper behavior from all the other countries in the world? Going back to one of the criticisms of the President, that the events in Ukraine are completely his fault due to his weakness, if that's the case you'd have to assume that there's never been a strong President because countries engage in all kinds of infractions on international treaties all the time. I would defy anyone to find a point in history where some country wasn't invading, interfering with or otherwise messing around with another country and not matter who is President of the United States it still goes on.
I hear some lamenting what they see as the end of American power or influence on the rest of the world. Considering how that's gone for us lately is that such a bad thing? Are there voices in other countries leveling the same critiques of their leaders? Why isn't England leading the way? Oh for the days when Germany barked out the orders and everyone snapped to attention! Secretary Kerry also made some comments about Russia taking a 19th century approach to the 21st century. Could it be that all this angst over what appears to be America's diminished role in controlling the fate of the world is just as out of place in the world of today?
Presidential critics who last week were decrying his dictator-like-iron-grip-tyrannical personality now see him as weak because no foreign country would dare break international law if a real leader occupied the White House. The dizzying speed at which some folks rush to condemn anything that President Obama (or his wife for that matter) says and does has yielded many silly moments and this may just be one more in the long line, not worth even trying to understand let alone answer. The prize for most ridiculous has to go to the chorus from the right praising Putin and holding him up as an example of how to be a leader. As a teacher though I'm always looking for teachable moments and possibilities for learning.
I asked many of my POTUS hating friends for suggestions on what they would do, and of course this is not a scientific study, but the answers I got where mostly not answers at all. One person suggested the same economic or political sanctions that are currently being discussed but everyone else couldn't come up with anything they would do. A more interesting point I think is why should the President of the United States be the one who guarantees proper behavior from all the other countries in the world? Going back to one of the criticisms of the President, that the events in Ukraine are completely his fault due to his weakness, if that's the case you'd have to assume that there's never been a strong President because countries engage in all kinds of infractions on international treaties all the time. I would defy anyone to find a point in history where some country wasn't invading, interfering with or otherwise messing around with another country and not matter who is President of the United States it still goes on.
I hear some lamenting what they see as the end of American power or influence on the rest of the world. Considering how that's gone for us lately is that such a bad thing? Are there voices in other countries leveling the same critiques of their leaders? Why isn't England leading the way? Oh for the days when Germany barked out the orders and everyone snapped to attention! Secretary Kerry also made some comments about Russia taking a 19th century approach to the 21st century. Could it be that all this angst over what appears to be America's diminished role in controlling the fate of the world is just as out of place in the world of today?
Tuesday, February 25, 2014
...and You Are There
One of my favorite TV shows in the days of my youth was "You Are There" which featured re-enactments of famous moments in history with the addition of a TV newsman, I think the show was on CBS so Walter Cronkite Mike Wallace might be interviewing General Custer before his famous battle or something like that. The idea of the show was wonderful, to put the viewer in the middle, as much as possible, or a history making event. To me, that's the point of studying history, to put ourselves into those moments that create change and try to understand the factors at work and how we are impacted by those events today.
Over the years teaching school I've often heard students express disbelief or disgust when studying the civil rights struggles of the 1950s and 60s. "How could people be so cruel?" or "How could people be so stupid? Don't they know everyone deserves equal rights?" These are common questions and challenging ones too. They are challenging because while you might be tempted to write off the bigots of the Citizen's Councils or the KKK as deviant members of society they represent the feelings and beliefs of a much larger, although not always as vocal, section of society.
As a teacher I have appreciated the current civil rights struggle for marriage equality on several levels. First, of course is the fact that people are demanding their equal rights and at the moment things are going well in the fight for equality, at least in the courts. Second, it gives today's students a chance to see a civil rights struggle play out. The voices against equality chant the same slogans and invoke the same religious traditions as they did a half century ago. The recent attempts at creating new laws that allow discrimination in states like Arizona even create the same photo opps of people being denied service at restaurants, hotels, and other public places. Students who have asked those questions and expressed disbelief at the bigotry on display need look no further than the front page of the paper or the evening news.
As before, those who hope to discriminate and seek legal backing to do so, act as if they are the ones being discriminated against. Talk to any true believer in the myth of the "Lost Cause of the Confederacy"and you'll get an earful about how terrible it was that they were denied the right to buy and sell humans. As recently as this past year a congress person used the phrase "The war of Northern Aggression" to describe the Civil War that was started by the Confederate States of America over their desire to continue slavery. Discrimination based on the color of one's skin was a time honored tradition sanctioned by religious beliefs that were near and dear to many people and this, I think, highlights another learning opportunity for us.
The leading voices against marriage equality all come from pretty much the same position, that allowing people the right to marry would infringe on the religious freedom of those who believe it is wrong. The recent attempts at legalizing discrimination in Arizona and Kansas go even further by saying that you should be able to discriminate against anyone who lives in a way you find objectionable. Of course a quick read-through of the Constitution should clear up any questions about making laws to enforce your particular religious beliefs on others and I would think a bit of common sense, if not common decency, would render the argument that your religious beliefs make it intolerable to encounter anyone who doesn't except your particular views as the gospel truth, seem rather ridiculous.
The opportunity that I see is for those students I've referred to and for those who support the founding documents and work for equality to develop some empathy for the bigotry.
I'm not talking about a free pass, I honestly believe that those claiming infringement of their religious liberties are misguided at best. I'm thinking more of trying to understand what fuels this resistance to equality. I realize that it may well come off as sounding patronizing and condescending "Oh those poor religious fundamentalists blah, blah..." If so, okay, that's my fault and I'll work on that, we don't all get things right the first time. When I think of students asking me about the KKK and people screaming at the Little Rock students walking to school I want to find ways to make those faces from the old black and white newsreels come to life. Today we have that opportunity. The people who fight equal rights may indeed be lovely people to spend time with. They might be your kind grandfather or your aunt, your mother or father. They may indeed be frightened that something important to them is being taken away. If you've grown up being taught that dark skin meant that the person was inferior and that it would threaten your world to allow them the same rights as you then to be told that your beliefs were bigoted, as true as that may be, would be a rude awakening. I've spoken to many friends in the past few years who are mightily offended by the notion that their opposition to marriage equality for example makes them a bigot. "Its not bigotry if you're discriminating because of a religious belief" one person told me. It seems to be a rude awakening or maybe a nightmare to think that you might be a fellow traveler with those hurling insults at Ruby Bridges fifty years ago.
One of the teachable moments we have right now is to remember that people are not two dimensional characters, they are much more complex. Those contorted faces screaming at African American children going to school have perhaps become more like fairy tale villains than real people who went to work, loved their families and lived real lives. Bigotry doesn't always look like evil on the surface. Sometimes it shows up as people who are friends or family who might belong the same church as you do who are expressing beliefs you have been taught to accept since you were a child. I think that we will be able to move forward as a society embracing and promoting equality which benefits us all if we can learn to recognize when that equality is threatened because it won't always be obvious.
History is playing out in front of us every day and perhaps when people study this time in the future and students ask "How could people have been so cruel? Didn't they realize that we all deserve equal rights?" Some of us will be around to remind each other that its not always so obvious when you are denying someone else their civil rights, especially if they look and act differently than us, and we'll encourage them to look around to see what, perhaps uncomfortable, opportunities exist to promote equality.
Over the years teaching school I've often heard students express disbelief or disgust when studying the civil rights struggles of the 1950s and 60s. "How could people be so cruel?" or "How could people be so stupid? Don't they know everyone deserves equal rights?" These are common questions and challenging ones too. They are challenging because while you might be tempted to write off the bigots of the Citizen's Councils or the KKK as deviant members of society they represent the feelings and beliefs of a much larger, although not always as vocal, section of society.
As a teacher I have appreciated the current civil rights struggle for marriage equality on several levels. First, of course is the fact that people are demanding their equal rights and at the moment things are going well in the fight for equality, at least in the courts. Second, it gives today's students a chance to see a civil rights struggle play out. The voices against equality chant the same slogans and invoke the same religious traditions as they did a half century ago. The recent attempts at creating new laws that allow discrimination in states like Arizona even create the same photo opps of people being denied service at restaurants, hotels, and other public places. Students who have asked those questions and expressed disbelief at the bigotry on display need look no further than the front page of the paper or the evening news.
As before, those who hope to discriminate and seek legal backing to do so, act as if they are the ones being discriminated against. Talk to any true believer in the myth of the "Lost Cause of the Confederacy"and you'll get an earful about how terrible it was that they were denied the right to buy and sell humans. As recently as this past year a congress person used the phrase "The war of Northern Aggression" to describe the Civil War that was started by the Confederate States of America over their desire to continue slavery. Discrimination based on the color of one's skin was a time honored tradition sanctioned by religious beliefs that were near and dear to many people and this, I think, highlights another learning opportunity for us.
The leading voices against marriage equality all come from pretty much the same position, that allowing people the right to marry would infringe on the religious freedom of those who believe it is wrong. The recent attempts at legalizing discrimination in Arizona and Kansas go even further by saying that you should be able to discriminate against anyone who lives in a way you find objectionable. Of course a quick read-through of the Constitution should clear up any questions about making laws to enforce your particular religious beliefs on others and I would think a bit of common sense, if not common decency, would render the argument that your religious beliefs make it intolerable to encounter anyone who doesn't except your particular views as the gospel truth, seem rather ridiculous.
The opportunity that I see is for those students I've referred to and for those who support the founding documents and work for equality to develop some empathy for the bigotry.
I'm not talking about a free pass, I honestly believe that those claiming infringement of their religious liberties are misguided at best. I'm thinking more of trying to understand what fuels this resistance to equality. I realize that it may well come off as sounding patronizing and condescending "Oh those poor religious fundamentalists blah, blah..." If so, okay, that's my fault and I'll work on that, we don't all get things right the first time. When I think of students asking me about the KKK and people screaming at the Little Rock students walking to school I want to find ways to make those faces from the old black and white newsreels come to life. Today we have that opportunity. The people who fight equal rights may indeed be lovely people to spend time with. They might be your kind grandfather or your aunt, your mother or father. They may indeed be frightened that something important to them is being taken away. If you've grown up being taught that dark skin meant that the person was inferior and that it would threaten your world to allow them the same rights as you then to be told that your beliefs were bigoted, as true as that may be, would be a rude awakening. I've spoken to many friends in the past few years who are mightily offended by the notion that their opposition to marriage equality for example makes them a bigot. "Its not bigotry if you're discriminating because of a religious belief" one person told me. It seems to be a rude awakening or maybe a nightmare to think that you might be a fellow traveler with those hurling insults at Ruby Bridges fifty years ago.
One of the teachable moments we have right now is to remember that people are not two dimensional characters, they are much more complex. Those contorted faces screaming at African American children going to school have perhaps become more like fairy tale villains than real people who went to work, loved their families and lived real lives. Bigotry doesn't always look like evil on the surface. Sometimes it shows up as people who are friends or family who might belong the same church as you do who are expressing beliefs you have been taught to accept since you were a child. I think that we will be able to move forward as a society embracing and promoting equality which benefits us all if we can learn to recognize when that equality is threatened because it won't always be obvious.
History is playing out in front of us every day and perhaps when people study this time in the future and students ask "How could people have been so cruel? Didn't they realize that we all deserve equal rights?" Some of us will be around to remind each other that its not always so obvious when you are denying someone else their civil rights, especially if they look and act differently than us, and we'll encourage them to look around to see what, perhaps uncomfortable, opportunities exist to promote equality.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


